Immigration and the burqa

3 04 2011

Growing up in America where rights to freedom of expression and equality are instilled since birth, the concept of clothing that discourages celebrating my body and my style, is completely foreign.

Wearing a burqa, an outer garment used to cover women’s bodies in public places, is still a common part of Muslim culture. Sometimes these garments are paired with a hijab that covers their heads, and a niqab that covers their eyes, stripping them of all individuality and personal image.

This is relevant to Spanish culture as immigration from Muslim countries to Spain continues to soar. According to an article on, “Spain currently has a Muslim population of slightly over 1 million, or about 2 percent of Spain’s total population. Spain has experienced a whopping ten-fold increase in the number of Muslim immigrants in just 20 years. The debate comes after the Spanish Senate, on June 23 [2010], voted 131 to 129 to “use all options under our legal system and to proceed with rules to prohibit the public use of the ‘burqa’ and the ‘niqab’ to ensure equality, freedom and security.”

There have been repeated accounts of discrimination and violence toward women in Spain dressed in traditional Muslim garb. This ban aims to ensure freedom, equality and security for these women.

The influx of Muslim immigrants also threatens to dilute Spanish culture as the Pew survey, sponsored by the Spanish government, reveals that only 46% of Muslim immigrants are fluent in Spanish. The survey also displayed a want for Muslim immigrants to maintain their culture and distinguish themselves from the larger Spanish society. They show no interest in assimilating to the Spanish customs or way of life.

“Almost 80 percent of the Spanish public sees Muslims as having a strong Islamic identity. Among those in the Spanish general public who see Islamic identity on the rise, 82 percent say it is a bad thing. Around 65 percent of Spaniards are somewhat or very concerned about rising Islamic extremism in their country,” the Pew Survey also reveals.

There are still questionable factors involved in this ban being approved based on the Spanish Constitution and the European Convention on Human Rights. While the Muslim community has a right to maintain their practices and traditional dress, but when women are facing discrimination and even physical abuse, the burqa seems to be causing more harm than good.




One response

30 06 2012
Brett Hetherington

To me, the only possible justification of a ban on wearing the burqa is for identification purposes at airports or other official government or business offices where a facial recognition/approval is needed. Apart from that, women, Muslim or otherwise, should not be compelled to show their faces because, my understanding of traditional Islamic practice is that only another woman [apart from close male relatives] should see their face. This is easy to arrange to be done in a private room in any situation where it is required, or in fact requested.

But wearing the hijab, the kippah or a crucifix is a personal decision, and should be seen along the same lines as wearing a particular team’s soccer shirt, or a t-shirt with a band name on it.”[ Javier Valenzuela writing in El Pais.]

My own logic would also suggest that unless there is a bigoted slogan on a t-shirt or depicts acts of violence then it should be allowed… (Or unless a student is half-naked) I see no reason to bother with them.

The enormous amounts of time and energy spent in schools (and recently the media) discussing and dealing with the subject of student’s clothing is ridiculous.

And why is this such a popular subject? Mainly, because it is a tangible subject. You can see it. It therefore suits the small-minded. It is easier to deal with than bullying, racism or the reluctance of many parents to be involved in their children’s education. So it gets the most attention, even though it does not deserve it.

BTW, as I read your post, my 11 year old son Hugo was playing nearby in his room, with his two best friends in our town: 2 Moroccan Muslim boys.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: